Tuesday, November 27, 2012

History Beckons!



Arvind Kejriwal is the man of the moment. He has successfully rallied the masses against the corrupt, self-serving rule of our politicians and has demanded reinstatement of the ideals of liberty, equality and justice, ideals on which this great democracy was founded. The middle class sees him as their saviour. Youngsters see him as their ideal. Many feel that finally someone has raised cudgels against the venal establishment that leads this nation. We are simply wowed by his commitment to his ideals, his recently formed "Aam Aadmi Party" and its impeccably worded constitution. 

I, for one, choose to be a bit cynical. Mr. Kejriwal's statements have been less than democratic on many occasions and I seriously doubt his commitment to democracy. He seems to forget that India, for all her inherent strength, is deeply divided on multiple counts. A 'one size fits all' kind of a approach is unlikely to work in our country. While Mr. Kejriwal's tirade against corruption may have won him support throughout the nation, it is highly unlikely that any policy decisions of his would gain widespread support unless he chooses to pursue the democratic path. What is needed is an emphasis on returning to the democratic ideals of discussion, deliberation and respect for the opposition. Over the past 60 years, we have succeeded in putting strong democratic systems in place, the need of the hour is to strengthen and sustain them. What India needs today is continuous evolution, not a revolution!

Maximilen de Robespierre was a nondescript character who came to the fore at the time of the French revolution in 1789. A skilled orator and an avowed revolutionary, he galvanized the masses, sickened as they were by the misrule of the King Louis XVI into creating a revolutionary France, governed by ideals of "Liberty, Equality and Fraternity". After having dispatched the King to the depths of hell, he turned his attention to the counter-revolutionaries in their midst. A reign of terror was instituted and thousands  of men and women alike were guillotined on flimsy charges. Idealism turned to a thirst for blood. All opposition became counter-revolutionary. The Guillotines in France worked overtime. The revolutionaries were now devouring the masses who had supported them in the first place. Any sign of dissent would land you on the guillotine. How did the madness end, you ask? The revolution ultimately consumed its own. Robespierre was guillotined by his own former supporters for having compromised the ideals of the republic. And the republic, where did it go? It would go down the drain as France, once again would became an empire, under Napoleon in a few years' time.

Mr. Kejriwal is no Robespierre. At least not today. But Robespierre was no Robespierre as we know him today when he first appeared on the political scene. India does not need a revolution today. It seeks stability, continuity and continuous and incremental change. It needs democracy to survive, It needs acceptance of problems and joint efforts for devising solutions. That is the only way forward.

One of Robespierre's quotes that resonates through history: "Citoyens, vouliez-vous une révolution sans révolution?" (Citizens, Did you want a revolution, without revolution?)

Monday, November 26, 2012

The heart of Africa



Dark clouds are gathering once again over the Congo river. The river is once again in spate, unleashing its waters violently across the land that had taken its name. Its once quiet, picturesque, meandering waters are now drowning homes, villages and towns, wrecking havoc like never before.

In a way, the Congo river mirrors the history of the country that has chosen to name itself after the river that brought sustenance to much of the country. Every now and then, marauding armies of rebels surface and challenge the puny government forces and civil war breaks out, bringing destruction and devastation similar to the fury, the river will soon unleash.

They say the Congo was plagued from its inception. An artificial Belgian created colony that overlooked tribal boundaries, its fate in the initial years was emblematic of the misfortune wrecked by naked colonial aggression. Congo was established as a personal fiefdom of the Belgian king who used all the might of his colonial enterprise of rob Congo of its rubber and its mineral resources. Congolese men and women  were maimed for life for failing to meet the colonial rubber quota. The Congo river drank the limbs that were thrown in its bosom, forced to swallow them as bitter poison.

Independence should have led to joy and national unification, but the century of Belgian rule had further exacerbated deep fissures within this artificial entity. Cold war struggles added their own complexities to what as already a boiling pot. Provinces, encouraged by the Europeans, fought for secession. The immensely popular but ideologically dogmatic Patrice Lumumba, the country's first Prime Minister was kidnapped and subsequently assassinated. They say, his remarks to the Belgian King, during the country's independence ceremony, "Nous ne sommes plus vos singes (We are no longer your monkeys)", earned him the ire of the Belgians, who were still in control of the nascent Congolese army. The Soviet attempt to create a Soviet satellite in the heart of Africa fizzled out with Lumumba's death. This paved he way for US proxy-intervention and the rise of the kleptocracy of Mobutu Sese Seko. Lip service was paid to the ideas of Lumumba but Congo was no more. In its place came Sese Seko's Zaire, corrupt and dictatorial. The river lost its identity too, it became the Zaire river and reflected the avarice and the greed of the nation as it devoured thousands in floods which it unleashed at its pleasure. 

And then the civil wars returned. Hutus fought Tutsis in neighboring Rwanda. Kabila fought Mobutu in Zaire as rebel movements sprouted everywhere. A tiny glimmer of light emerged as a government established its authority and resurrected the Congo. However, the joy was short-lived. Wars broke out in the north, the south, the East and the West. Flawed elections fueled public discontent. Rebels gained courage to declare war on the government. They resorted to violence, rape, arson and loot. Children were kidnapped, Women disappeared. The artificial calm that had existed for years was shattered again. Neighbours financed rebels as Congolese fought Congolese. River Congo wept bitterly seeing the death, the destruction and the devastation wrecked by her own children on their own land.

They say the Congo will continue to flood and devour victims till peace returns to its namesake nation. The international community cannot afford to look at the Congo conflict as an experimentation in nation hood. Democracy and the rule of law have to prevail in Congo. The international community must commit itself to that. Congo has been ravaged enough, for its minerals, for its rubber. Now is the time for Congo to join the community of nations as a truly independent nation, standing on its own two feet. The failure of Congo will be a costly affair, there is no doubt that If Congo goes, it will take most of Africa, with its borders cutting across tribal homelands and language groups,  down with it. 

Monday, November 19, 2012

Philosophical ramblings!



So, Who am I? Am I just a character, put on this planet by a mysterious force (lets call it God), to play my part in the script written down by him. Or am I a thinking being who can decide for himself, who is susceptible to influences and who can influence outcomes? Or, is it that I am the ruler of my destiny, the determiner of all outcomes and the ruler of my fate.

Which brings us to the nebulous concept of fate. Is there anything like fate? Eastern thought imparts an automatic feeling of there being mysterious forces beyond the control of a man. However, more often than not, when things go right, they are attributable to a man's wisdom, his attitude, his drive, but the moment things do not work out, it is fate at play. Western thought lays emphasis on the being. Communists for instance see fate as something that the upper classes threw in the face of the poorer sections of the society to keep them in abject poverty. It is the man, in western thought, who can bring about results by his own determination.

Which now brings us to the abstraction of determination. Why is it that a man might show determination to do one thing, while lacking any willingness to do another. Or, why is it that we exert ourselves to do something at one point of time, while showing no inclination for the same thing some other time. If you attribute this to 'mood', then why is it that our mood fluctuates so wildly. Why is it that we are so prone to external influences. Why is it that the mind, sometimes, behaves as though it were independent of the body, while at times, it behaves as though it were a prisoner of the same body? Determination appears to be a function of many factors, most of which lie beyond one's control. Ultimately, do we decide our own actions or not, or is there something more sinister at play, something that we have already called fate.

Is there fate? If so, who scripts this fate? Is there God? If there is, what/where/how/who is he? 

Or, once again, am I just a character put on this planet, playing out my part. Doubting others, when the script asks me to, doubting myself, when the script so commands. Pausing at the right moments and rushing at the right parts… All as per the script!

Sunday, September 23, 2012

Goodbye Lenin!



Imagine you wake up one day to find that the world as you knew it has turned upside down…. That which was profane is suddenly sacred, that which was fiendish is suddenly saintly, that which was adored has now been cast aside… What would you do? This is what happened to Christiane Kerner, when she awoke from her 8 month long coma in an East Berlin Hospital in the autumn of 1989… She was a proud, socialist citizen of the German Democratic Republic, but within these 8 months, her Socialist homeland, the paradise of workers and farmers had ceased to exist.. except in her head… 'Goodbye Lenin!'  is an amazing description of the travails of the Kerner family and the emotional roller coaster that the family embarks on to preserve the now-dead Socialist fatherland for the sake of Christiane.

It is easy for us, 20 years later, to say that the wretched communist system was bound to fail before the burgeoning power of the Capitalist West. But for those who lived it, It was the only life they knew. State subsidized education, State sponsored welfare, long queues for foodstuffs, cars, whose deliveries took decades… so on and so forth… May be they hated it, may be they loved it… What is important is, they lived it… They got used to a style of living, where life proceeded at its leisurely pace… There was none of this madness about time and advertising and marketing…Even our parents' generation, used to a semi-socialist Nehruvian lifestyle are today at times amazed at how "easily" we get things and how there are maddening choices and cut throat competition for everything!

This life suddenly met its full stop in the revolutions that engulfed East Europe in 1989-90. A whole lifestyle came to an abrupt end. And with this end, an entire generation that had breathed and lived this lifestyle, found itself struggling to comprehend the enormity of change that had overcome them… Most of them stayed afloat, armed with the skills that their previous lifestyle had provided them… A few went down under… Christiane Kerner was one of them… She lived for her Socialist homeland, and even though she personally detested it, she remained loyal and committed to it till the end came… Both for her and her Socialist fatherland.

Goodbye Lenin! along with Das Leben der anderen and Der Baader-Meinhoff Komplex are some of the best movies to watch on a country whose very existence was an aberration but which lived its life, sometimes reaching for the stars and at other times convulsed in epileptic seizures… And while we are still on the subject of the German Democratic Republic, I strongly recommend a reading of Stasiland by Anna Funder to understand better the strange but enrapturing world of the German Socialist Fatherland!

Here is to the GDR!

"Alles mit dem Volk
Alles durch das Volk
Alles für das Volk! "

Wednesday, September 19, 2012

Ganpati Bappa Morya!


Ganesh idols in different hues
Hawa Mahal shaped Pandal

Dagdu Sheth Ganpati inside the Pandal
Old Pune was the place to be in today. Streets decked up, shops decorated, crowds milling, giant pandals and what not. The whole place seemed to be reverberating with some mysterious energy. Everyone knew today was Ganesh Chaturthi, but the pandals were still empty, their emptiness magnified by their immense size. But the crowds, they kept on growing- Ladies in traditional attire, holding plates of offering, Men with their foreheads decked with tilaks and the kids mingling with the crowds, yelling "Ganpati Bappa Morya".

And then suddenly, the crowds went berserk... A huge shout erupted from one end of the street... Before you could even make sense of what was going on, the sound of drums broke through the place. Dholaks and Mridangs and young men representing their Mandal beating their instruments ferociously as Lord Ganesh came into view- aesthetically coloured, decked with ornaments, stationed on a beautifully furnished cart, making its way to its ornately decorated Pandal- as though announcing his presence!

Cries of 'Ganpati Bappa Morya' resonated through the air as Ganesh made its way to the pandal. Crowds, spontaneously broke into a dance. There was no caste, no class, no religion- just India- The way it is and the way it should be. The foreigners, bemused looked on, as some of their compatriots joined the dancing crowds.

It reminded me of Durga Puja in Kolkata 3 years ago. There too, I had seen the same level of fervour, excitement and oneness that just grows on you. For a farji Marathi like me, this was my first Ganesh Chaturthi and I loved every moment of it!

Sunday, September 2, 2012

Damn the Autowallah!



Thats it! The vilest, most evil and the most god forsaken bunch of people on the face of this earth are the autowallahs! Yep, they are a distinct group- bloodsucking, rash driving, rude talking, bunch of thieves- Thats what they are. And I am not going to apologize for generalizing so brazenly! Be it Delhi, Bangalore, Bhopal or Pune, these autowallahs are there not to serve people but to fleece them! They don't give a damn to sarkari rates and their meter is just another gizmo or another accoutrement in their glitzy vehicle adorned with pics of ex-heroines who are now grandmothers! 

It just keeps happening! You haggle with an autowallah, agree to pay 100 for what you know for sure costs 80 and then when you get down, you haggle again, 'coz either the distance was longer or there was a traffic jam or its suddenly turned dark or the clouds are on the horizon! And don't be deceived when an autowallah agrees to go by the meter, it only means you're screwed! A meter that runs is more dangerous than the dead one! Oh and when you desperately need an auto, the autowallah will bluntly refuse to indulge you, if you insist, he will quote an outrageous price that will make your blood boil! And the worst part is, that in this country of Anna Hazare and Arvind Kejriwal, there is noone to raise his voice against the tyranny of these autowallahs. I mean they are all politically-connected. Everytime they want to raise fares for whatever flimsy reason, they just go on a strike and you are left with long queues of people waiting to get to office or home or wherever. The government is only glad to buckle under the pressure- they are an important vote bank now aren't they!

And so there seems to be no end in sight to the tyranny of these autowallahs. Well, lets admit it, those who can afford it, will call those cool cabs and those who can't will travel by state buses. It leaves only those who are sandwiched in between. And since these losers (myself included) definitely don't count, I guess La terreur of autowallahs will continue!

Wednesday, August 29, 2012

Press release by Digvijay Singh


Countrymen, Today we should hang our heads in shame. This nation of Jawaharlal Nehru, Indira Gandhi, Rajiv Gandhi, Sonia Gandhi, Rahul Gandhi, Priyanka Gandhi and oh yes Mahatma Gandhi has been disgraced today. Our honourable Supreme Court has passed a decision that smacks of communalism and religious bigotry. Ajmal Kasab has been handed the death sentence. I, for one, find it shocking. Does it not dishonour our collective national conscience that a member of the minority committee has been sentenced to death by the highest court of law of a secular nation? Is this what it has come to? This is brazen abuse of the ideals of secularism that the fathers of our constitution had scripted. Are we a Saudi Arabia or a Pakistan, where members of the minority community have no rights? 

Facts first. Ajmal Kasab was caught allegedly during the Mumbai carnage in 2008, this has yet to be proven. I have substantial evidence on how TV clippings were doctored to incriminate an innocent member of the minority community. Who is to prove that he was not one of the victims of the carnage? The very fact that the Maharashtra Police arrested him and kept him in prison for 4 years makes him a victim of the Mumbai attacks. Oh! What tortures he would have had to bear, and that too when he is a member of the minority community! And for God's sakes, he was fed Biryani at a time when even school going kids eat only Subways! Hasn't the country gravely harmed the physical well being of a member of the minority committee by doing so? And to top it all, he is being sentenced to death. What a mockery of justice!

To wash away the sins of this nation, I propose the following-

i. Death sentence of Ajmal Kasab to be cast aside. He will be nominated by my Congress party as a candidate for Lok Sabha for 2014 elections from Mumbai South constituency.

ii. Minority quota of 67% to be introduced for all legislative assemblies and Parliament. This will be over and above the quota for SC/ST/OBC etc.

iii. Mumbai to be renamed Ajmalabad or Kasababad. 

Long Live Madam Sonia Gandhi!

Friday, August 17, 2012

Its raining expectations



Its scary. All these expectations, I tell you. 3 years of corporate life has meant that I am (decently) financially independent. And just when you thought you could do whatever it was you wanted to do for all these years, expectations pop up. Well actually, they pour down… incessantly…. Buy a car….Get your own place to stay… Book a flat… Get married… Settle down…. Get a better job...Get serious about life… Blah blah  blah blah…. Family goes crazy, peer pressure mounts... I mean, how is a man to live like this!

The worst are the comparisons. You know him, he has bought his second car…. That friend of his, he got engaged last month…. That person who stays near our place, he booked a flat…. That acquaintance switched jobs, he now earns gazillions...Can't even believe you are still living like an animal…

And so the expectations keep pouring in.. One after the other… Sometimes, I get irritated, at other times, I get depressed…Some times, I laugh them off… At other times, I confront, I argue, even ask people to shut up… But mostly, I listen, I smile and tell myself… This too shall pass :)

Oh India!



I guess India was founded on ideals that were too lofty, too idealistic and unsustainable in the long run. I mean there is probably no other nation in the world which has been forged together with such disparate groups whose interests are so different, and at most times antagonistic to each other. Probably, the Balkanization of India is inevitable. We can only pray that it doesn't happen in our lifetime, because it is guaranteed to be messy, bloody and chaotic!

Lets accept it, the concept of India as a nation is only 60 years old. There has never existed an Indian nation, ever in the history. There have been empires of Ashoka, the Mughals, the Marathas etc., but there has never been an India, united in mind, or in body. Hindu nationalists point towards the great empire of Shivaji's descendants, who united India, 'from Attock to Cuttack', as they say. This was barely a state, with warlords ruling and with the local populace having no common cause with the plundering, ravaging raids of the Maratha army. The Mughal empire united the entire subcontinent, but the overwhelming majority remained hostile to the rule of outsiders, whose customs and rituals, they could never relate to. British India, was never even a state. It was a patchwork of territories occupied by cunning Britishers, fiefdoms and despotic kingdoms.

The concept of India or Akhand Bharat, personified by Bharat Mata, came to the fore only at the time of Independence. Fanned by Congress and Hindu nationalists alike, it succeeded in laying the foundation of the concept of the Indian nation, but antagonized the Muslims, many of whom eventually seceded from what they perceived would be Hindu hegemony. And thus was born India, for the first time in history- divided by caste, creed, religion, customs and what not, United, only by its recent struggle for independence.

The moth eaten India (unlike the envisaged Akhand Bharat) could endure for eternity if the ruling political classes chose to 'Put India first'. But they chose to put the interests of their vote banks before the nation. So you have Mayawati, courting the Dalits, bringing disgrace to Babasaheb Ambedkar's legacy that she proclaims to uphold, you have Narendra Modi, who, till a few years ago, was spewing venom against the Muslims, you have Rahul Baba, who sometimes woos Muslims, and sometimes woos Dalits- Well whatever gets him a seat in UP! This race of politicians, united in their rejection of the idea of India has threatened the very existence of the nation.

The Assam violence and the corresponding flight of North easterners should not be viewed as an isolated event. Along with instances such as the Gujarat riots, the flight of the Kashmiri Pandits, the anti-sikh pogrom etc.,  it threatens to tear this nation apart. For whatever be the ideals, lofty, idealistic or unsustainable, this nation has endured for 60 years! It has given hope and opportunity to millions. India is already surrounded by a string of failed states on all sides. Look at what their leaders have done to their people, what abject misery those populations have been reduced to. For all its shortcomings and structural fallacies, India needs to endure. There is no other alternative.

Wednesday, May 23, 2012

A tale of two Queens-Part I




"If they don't have bread, let them eat cake"… This statement attributed to Marie Antoinette is apocryphal. She never did utter these words… The Austrian born, Queen of France, wasn't even aware of the state of affairs in France outside her luxurious, opulent royal palace at Versailles. All she probably cared for was her jewels, her dresses, her husband and her children…

France detested her… The Parisians, tired of the rising prices of bread and the apparent impoverishment of the once magnificent nation, called her L'autre chienne (the other bitch!), a pun on the word "L'Autrichienne (The Austrian)… There were stories on the extent of debauchery within the royal household… There were tales that called her a whore...and a drunken whore at that. Frankly, France had never taken a liking to this Austrian princess who had married into French royalty. The wedding, albeit, a political masterpiece that ended centuries of hostility between France and Austria, had failed to impress the masses…She remained too distant, too aloof for the masses to even attempt to like her…

France, for all that Marie cared, could rot in hell. She never did like the formal, aristocratic court culture in Versailles. She didn't like the continuous intrusions into her private life. She didn't like it that she was constantly told to behave like a Queen of France. She did not like the restrictions that were placed on her. And she did not like it that her own Husband would not indulge her… While France alleged that the Queen was barren, when she failed to produce a heir for several years after marriage, she knew that the fault lay with the King of France. Her personal life, probably had more in common with the life of her subjects outside Versailles- impoverished, unhappy and frustrating. What she couldn't find in her husband and the royal court, she found in jewels and dresses and later, in her own children.

France, in the meanwhile continued to smolder... Dissatisfaction gave way to full blown mutiny...Marie was shocked at the extent of disenchantment and discontentment with which the masses greeted her when the French Revolution broke out… Evicted from Versailles, the royal family lived under the vigilant eyes of revolutionary Parisians. The Austrian invasion against revolutionary France, coupled with the threat that Paris would be obliterated if any harm came to the royal couple did not endear the Queen to her captors. The revolutionaries came to regard L'autre chienne as the traitor of the worst order. Her life, they reasoned would imply death for revolutionary France...

And so, even though the revolution had already devoured her husband, the King, it proceeded to try the Queen. She was accused of being an Austrian spy, of having sold out the wealth of France to Austria, of having done disservice to her adopted nation and the most ridiculous of them all, of having indulged in incestuous relationship with her children. Marie, who had so far listened to the charges, with her head bowed low, with an acceptance of the fate that awaited her, now broke her silence. Trembling with rage, it was the mother and not the Queen who now addressed the court. She accused the revolutionaries of having dishonored her, of having taken her children away from her, of having reduced her to a wretched existence, of having made her a widow and probably having already murdered her children too. She looked at the common womenfolk who had assembled to watch the trial and asked them what her crime was. She demanded compassion, she demanded justice… She demanded liberty…

There was a collective gasp from the assembled womenfolk… The revolutionary court would not permit the revolution to be unravelled in its very own presence. The judgment was swift and crisp. Marie knew the outcome…She was to be guillotined.

A wooden cart used to transport criminals to the Guillotine awaited the former Queen of France. Her "revolutionary" captors thought this would befit a former Queen who had now been reduced to a citizen. She was marched through the streets of Paris. Among boos and jeers, she tried to maintain her dignity. She remained calm. She had hated behaving like the Queen of France all her life, but she was ready to greet death as nothing less than the Queen of France.

The Guillotine came down with a loud thud. Marie Antoinette never did get a chance to like France.